The hypothesis is tested that enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) can be used to quantify the aqueous spaces of living cells, using as a model transgenic Xenopus rods. Consistent with the hypothesis, regions of rods having structures that exclude EGFP, such as the mitochondrial-rich ellipsoid and the outer segments, have highly reduced EGFP fluorescence. Over a 300-fold range of expression the average EGFP concentration in the outer segment was approximately half that in the most intensely fluorescent regions of the inner segment, in quantitative agreement with prior X-ray diffraction estimates of outer segment cytoplasmic volume. In contrast, the fluorescence of soluble arrestin-EGFP fusion protein in the dark adapted rod outer segment was approximately threefold lower than predicted by the EGFP distribution, establishing that the fusion protein is not equilibrated with the cytoplasm. Arrestin-EGFP mass was conserved during a large-scale, light-driven redistribution in which ∼40% of the protein in the inner segment moved to the outer segment in less than 30 minutes.
Many cell functions depend on a polarized, non-equilibrium distribution of molecular constituents. Photoreceptors provide an excellent example in that both soluble and membrane-associated components of phototransduction function in a cellular compartment distinct from the site of macromolecular synthesis. The mechanisms that establish and maintain this polarity remain poorly defined, especially in the case of soluble proteins, but ultimately depend on a detailed understanding the cytoplasmic space through which macromolecules move. Efforts to characterize the cytoplasmic space with fluorescent molecular probes of various sizes have revealed a size-dependent partitioning into different subcellular regions (Janson et al., 1996; Luby-Phelps, 2000). The most likely explanation of this partitioning is `sieving', i.e. the existence of compartments to which access depends on particle size. Quantification of the cytoplasmic space accessible to macromolecules of varying sizes is critical for defining the equilibrium distribution of a soluble macromolecule in a cell, thus providing a baseline against which nonequilibrium can be gauged.
A current problem involving the equilibrium distribution of soluble macromolecules is provided by the rod protein arrestin. Arrestin is an abundant soluble protein that plays an essential role in phototransduction by `capping' phosphorylated rhodopsin (Wilden et al., 1986; Xu et al., 1997). Arrestin undergoes a large-scale redistribution from the inner segment (IS) to the outer segment (OS) in rods after light exposure (Broekhuyse et al., 1985; Broekhuyse et al., 1987; Philp et al., 1987; Whelan and McGinnis, 1988; Mendez et al., 2003; Peterson et al., 2003). But questions remain open about whether the initial distribution of arrestin in a dark adapted rod is determined by the relative water spaces of the compartments or by other factors such as specific binding, and to what degree active or passive processes govern its redistribution upon illumination.
To address such questions, we have used enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) as a probe of the cytoplasmic space of living cells. Our experiments test the hypothesis that EGFP can serve as a quantitative measure of the cytoplasmic space. We quantify the expression of EGFP in living CHO cells and rod photoreceptors by using 3D laser scanning confocal microscopy. The distribution of EGFP in both cell types is consistent with the hypothesis that local EGFP fluorescence is proportional to the local aqueous volume fraction. We then examine transgenic Xenopus rods expressing an arrestin-EGFP fusion protein, and show that in the dark adapted state this soluble protein has a distribution highly distinct from that of EGFP, and thus not in equilibrium with the cytoplasm. Finally we show that upon light-driven redistribution from the inner segment (IS) to the outer segment (OS), arrestin-EGFP obeys conservation of mass, rejecting the hypothesis that degradation and/or synthesis underlie the redistribution.
Materials and Methods
Description of the confocal laser scanning microscope and its calibration
We constructed a confocal laser scanning microscope (CLSM) based on the physical design and C++ image acquisition software of Hollingworth et al. (Hollingworth et al., 2001), using a TE300 inverted microscope (Nikon) fitted with a CFI60 (60×, 1.2 NA), water-immersion objective. The 3D point-spread function of the CLSM was measured with 0.1 μm diameter fluorescent microspheres. The normal scanning parameters were: x-y field size, 100 μm × 100 μm at 0.4 μm per pixel; z-step, 0.5 μm; voxel collection time 24 μs (cf. Suppl. data for details: http://jcs.biologists.org/supplemental/).
The relationship between the CLSM signal and EGFP concentration, [EGFP], was determined by scanning a 15 μl chamber loaded with solutions of recombinant protein (Cat. no. 8365-1 Clontech, Palo Alto, CA) whose concentration was determined with a spectrophotometer (λ20 UV/Vis, Perkin-Elmer), using published spectra and an extinction coefficient ϵmax=55,000 cm2 mmol-1 at 488 nm (Tsien, 1998). This relationship between excitation intensity I, [EGFP] and fluorescence F was found to be described by a bilinear function of the two independent variables: 1
where Imax is the maximum intensity, D the density of any filters in the excitation beam, and K a constant. Eqn 1 was inverted to estimate [EGFP] in living cells: thus, in the voxel at position (x, y, z) 2
Transgenic Xenopus and CHO cells: arrestin-EGFP fusion construct
The REMI method was used to create transgenic Xenopus, with EFGP and arrestin-EGFP (Arr-EGFP) fusion protein expression driven by the opsin promoter (Mani et al., 1999; Mani et al., 2001). CHO cells stably expressing EGFP were created with standard methods; the constructs are described in the supplemental data (Materials and Methods, Sections 2-5, http://jcs.biologists.org/supplemental/).
Quantitative western blotting and fluorimetry
For western blotting of CHO cells, the pellet of 1×106 cells was resuspended in 100 μl of non-denaturing lysis buffer (1% w/v Triton X-100; 50 mM TrisCl, pH=7.4, 300 mM NaCl, 5 mM EDTA, and protease inhibitor), kept on ice for 30 minutes, and spun at 21,000 g for 30 min at 4°C, and the supernatant collected. In control experiments to determine the maximum yield of protein, the resuspended material was sonicated 5× or subjected to freeze/thaw cycles. Western blotting of cell lysates was performed by running 10 μl of the supernatant on an SDS-PAGE gel calibrated with prestained molecular weight standards (Cat. no. 161-0372, BioRad), along with lanes containing 10 μl aliquots of rEGFP or rGFP (Clontech) whose concentrations were determined spectrophotometrically. An equivalent aliquot of supernatant of lysed non-expressing g1651a CHO cells was run as a control. After the initial electrophoresis, the gel contents were transferred electrophoretically to a nitrocellulose filter, blocked for 1 hour with 1% dry milk and exposed to EGFP antibody (Clontech, Cat. no. 8367 or Roche, Cat. no. 1814460) at 1/100 dilution in 1% dry milk PBS/Tween solution. The filter was then washed, exposed to a secondary antibody conjugated to alkaline phosphatase and washed again. Finally it was exposed to ECF substrate, fluorescence measured with a Storm phosphosphoimager and quantified with ImageQuant™ software (Molecular Dynamics).
The mass of EGFP in lysates of CHO cells was estimated fluorimetrically by scanning 20 μl aliquots with the CLSM, as was done with recombinant EGFP (Fig. S2, http://jcs.biologists.org/supplemental/). The total mass of protein was computed as the product of the concentration of EGFP multiplied by the lysate volume.
Recording chamber and basic protocol for living cells
The recording chamber was fabricated from plastic Petri dishes from whose center an ∼3×3 mm cutout was milled; a number 1 coverslip was affixed to the bottom with wax, creating a volume of ca. 15 μl that could be readily searched. CHO cells passed into PBS or small pieces of dark-adapted Xenopus retina dissected under infrared illumination in oxygenated Ringer's solution (in mM: NaCl 111, KCl 2, CaCl2 1, MgCl2 1, MgSO4 0.5, NaH2PO4 0.5, HEPES 3, glucose 10, EDTA 0.01) were loaded into the chamber, after which it was sealed with a coverslip and vacuum grease. The experimental conditions were essentially those used in our laboratories for electrical recordings from amphibian photoreceptors. For the experiments with Arr-EGFP, all manipulations of the tissue, including the location of the cells to be scanned with the CLSM in the recording chamber, were performed with infrared light. Two steps were taken to avoid selection bias: (1) the chamber was initially viewed under infrared illumination and a piece of retina having the largest number of well oriented, contiguous rods selected; (2) in the offline data analysis, every intact rod scanned was processed.
Image segmentation and analysis of confocal data from cells
A user-driven interface was created with the Matlab programming language (Mathworks, Natick, MA) for the segmentation of CLSM data from CHO and rod cells (see supplemental data, Materials and Methods, Section 6, http://jcs.biologists.org/supplemental/). This `3D cookie cutter' allowed the 3D CLSM data of individual cells to be extracted from stacks of images and processed for further analysis. The concentration of EGFP in each voxel of a cell was determined with Eqn 2, and other statistics, including envelope cell dimensions and envelope volume, were computed. The total mass of EGFP in each cell was obtained by summing over the voxels defining the cell. A distinctive feature of the rod cell analysis was the derivation of a spline, measuring 1.6 μm in the x- and y-dimensions and 1 μm in the z dimension, along the central `core' of each cell's 3D data.
Electron microscopy and immunohistochemistry
For EM, eyes from euthanized animals were fixed in 1.65% glutaraldehyde and 1% OsO4 in phosphate buffer and embedded in epoxy resin as previously described (Pazour et al., 2002). For immunohistochemistry, eyes were placed in 4% paraformaldehyde in PBS at 4°C overnight, incubated overnight in 30% sucrose in PBS at 4°C, frozen in OCT and sectioned at 20 μm with a Leica CM 1850 cryostat. Sections were then blocked for 30 minutes and the primary antibody applied overnight at 4°C. The sections were then washed three times with PBS, and the secondary antibody applied for 1 hour. Primary antibodies and dilutions employed were against cytochrome c (1:250; Sigma, St Louis, MO), acetylated α-tubulin (1:1500; Sigma). Appropriate secondary antibodies conjugated to Cy3 (Jackson ImmunoResearch, West Grove, PA) and Alexa 555 (Molecular Probes, Eugene, OR) were used to complement EGFP fluorescence. After the final wash, sections were mounted with medium containing DAPI (Vectashield, Vector Laboratories, Burlingame, CA) and imaged with a Zeiss LSM-510 confocal microscope.
Quantifying EGFP expression in CHO cells
Analysis with confocal laser scanning microscopy (CLSM)
To establish the accuracy of the CLSM for quantifying EGFP expression in living cells, we measured the fluorescence of a line of CHO cells (pDP3) that express EGFP, and compared the EGFP mass per cell estimated from CLSM data with the mass estimated by western blotting and fluorimetry. CHO cells were approximately spherical in shape, but varied in their volume and in their average fluorescence (Fig. 1). The average pDP3 cell volume determined with the CLSM was 1.17±0.54 pl (mean±s.d., n=485 cells). We determined the amount of EGFP in each voxel and summed the amounts over the cell volume to estimate the total mass of EGFP per cell. The average EGFP mass per cell was 6.9±0.8 attomols/cell (Table 1). A potential source of error is autofluorescence: however, the fluorescence intensity of control cells was more than 100-fold reduced from that of pDP3 cells (Fig. 1D), and so autofluorescence had negligible effect on the estimation of the EGFP concentration.
Quantitative western blotting and fluorimetry
Western blotting of pDP3 cell lysates yielded the estimate 5.1±1.8 attomols/cell, while fluorimetric analysis of aliquots of the same lysates yielded the estimate 5.4±1.1 attomols/cell (Fig. 2; Table 1). CHO cells not expressing EGFP gave no signal on western blots, but the autofluorescence of their lysate was measured and found to be more than 100-fold lower than the fluorescence of pDP3 cell lysate (Fig. 2). The western blotting and fluorimetry establish that the local fluorescence intensity of EGFP as measured with our photon-counting CLSM accurately reflects the local EGFP concentration, and can be used to derive quantitative estimates of the mass of EGFP in living cells.
The average concentration of EGFP in pDP3 cells estimated with analysis of the CLSM data was ∼6 μM (6.9×10-18 mols/1.2×10-12 l), but ranged about 30-fold, from 0.7 to 20 μM over the population (Fig. 1C). This concentration variation provides grounds for testing the hypothesis that the distribution of EGFP reflects the local aqueous space of the cells.
EGFP equilibration hypothesis
EGFP is highly soluble and diffuses in cultured cells faster than any protein in its molecular weight class (Luby-Phelps, 2000). The rapid diffusion of EGFP in cells indicates that it interacts little with other cellular constituents, and suggests to us that it can serve as a marker for the local `water fraction' of the cell. We formulate this idea as an hypothesis: `EGFP is in equilibrium with the cell's cytoplasm'.
This hypothesis predicts that the ratio of the EGFP fluorescence intensity of a given volume element (voxel) to the maximal local fluorescence intensity of the cell should provide an estimate of the voxel's fractional aqueous space: thus, 3
where faq,voxel is the fraction of the voxel at location (x, y, z) to which EGFP has ready access, F is the fluorescence intensity, and Fmax the maximum fluorescence. We estimated faq, cell, the fraction of aqueous space of each cell, by calculating Eqn 3 for every voxel of the cell, and then averaging over the cell volume. The value of Fmax was taken to be the average fluorescence intensity of the voxels of the cell comprising the upper Mth percentile of intensities, for M≥95%: the estimates were faq,cell=0.53±0.06 for M=95% and faq,cell=0.48±0.06 for M=99%. The value faq,cell=0.54 is given in Alberts et al. [Table 12-2 (Alberts et al., 1994)] for hepatocytes. We tested for dependence of faq,cell on cell volume and expression level by partitioning the fluorescence data into 15 roughly equally populated bins defined by volume and average fluorescence intensity (Fig. 1D, dashed lines): there was no dependence of faq,cell on cell volume, but it is about 15% lower for cells in the lowest third of the distribution of intensities than for those in the highest.
Quantifying variation in the expression of EGFP among neighboring rods
Preliminary CLSM scans of isolated rods had fluorescence intensity distributions which appeared distinct from those of rods in intact pieces of retina, leading to the inference that separating rods from the retina initiated structural changes. Consequently, quantitative investigation required the use of small pieces of intact retina. In the intact retina rods are elongated, with several domains of distinctive structure and content and with neighbors exhibiting varying levels of EGFP fluorescence (Fig. 3), and so present several distinct challenges for quantifying expression.
Analysis of the spatial distribution of EGFP in individual rods
Using a `3D cookie cutting' method we analyzed the spatial distribution of EGFP in a population of rods (Figs 4, 6, 7, 8). The distribution of one rod excised from the scan data of Fig. 3B reveals several features of the EGFP distribution, including from left to right: the synaptic spherule, a brightly fluorescent nuclear and inner segment region, a dim segment tentatively identified as the ellipsoid by its position, followed by a relatively uniform outer segment whose distal tip is somewhat brighter (Fig. 4A). These features are quantified by plotting the fluorescence intensity distribution or profile along the `core' of the cell (Fig. 4B, thickened red line), along with the profile distributions of seven other rods whose images were excised from the scan data of the same piece of retina (Fig. 3).
The EGFP equilibration hypothesis predicts that the profile distributions, when appropriately scaled, should be independent of the expression level. To test this we divided the fluorescence profile distribution of each rod by its maximum fluorescence intensity; these normalized profile distributions are plotted along with the average normalized profile of the 15 rods (Fig. 4C) scanned in the experiment shown in Fig. 3. The average profile of 57 rods scanned in 12 pieces of retina from 4 animals is very similar to that of the 15 rods from one piece of retina (Fig. 4D).
Features of the rod cytoplasm revealed by EGFP
Several distinctive features of the rod are highlighted by the EGFP profile distributions (Fig. 4). First, in each rod the most intense EGFP fluorescence is found in a broad region that surrounds and includes the nucleus. The apparently high aqueous volume fraction in this region is expected from many classic ultrastructural investigations, from experiments with small molecular weight fluorescent dyes (Olson and Pugh, 1993), and from the accessibility of the nucleus to EGFP (Keminer and Peters, 1999; Moritz et al., 1999) (Fig. 5B). Second, each rod exhibits a sharp decrease in fluorescence intensity just to the left of the relatively flat profile along the OS (Fig. 4). This decrease can be unequivocally identified with the ellipsoid region of the rod which is densely packed with mitochondria, confirmed immunohistochemically with antibodies to cytochrome c (Fig. 5B) and by EM (Fig. 5E-G). The lowered EGFP fluorescence intensity in the ellipsoid region in living rods is qualitatively consistent with the EGFP equilibrium hypothesis, on the assumption that EGFP is excluded from the water space of the mitochondria. Third, every rod exhibits a bright fluorescent spot localized to the top and one side the ellipsoid (cf. Fig. 3B, red arrows; Fig. 5A, white arrows). Immunolabeling with an antibody against α-tubulin shows that this feature corresponds to the region of the basal body, where the cilium connecting the IS and OS originates (Fig. 5C,D). Histochemistry (Fig. 5B) and EMs (Fig. 5E-H) confirm that a space devoid of mitochondria is present there. Fourth, most rods exhibit a region of increased EGFP fluorescence that encompasses the tip of the outer segment (Fig. 4B,C). This latter feature is not so readily seen in the averaged profile distributions (Fig. 4D) as in the profiles of individual rods. The feature is diminished by averaging because the cell profiles were aligned at the junction of the IS and OS, but the OSs varied in the length. The third and fourth features revealed by EGFP have not been identified previously in ultrastructural studies in terms of increased aqueous volume fractions, and highlight the utility of EGFP for uncovering novel structural features of cells.
A quantitative test of the EGFP equilibration hypothesis
A quantitative prediction of the EGFP equilibration hypothesis can be derived from the ultrastructure of the rod determined from X-ray diffraction and neutron scattering by living rods (Table 2). Such data reveal that rod discs, which are closed to the cytoplasm (Chen et al., 2002), occupy about 50% of the envelope volume in the `core' of the OS. Thus, the hypothesis predicts that fluorescence in the OS core should be about 50% of the maximal fluorescence in the rod. This prediction is borne out by the average, normalized profiles: along the OS the normalized profiles are very near 50% (Fig. 4C,D). This prediction is further examined in Fig. 6, whose upper panel plots the apparent concentration of EGFP along the OS core as a function of the maximal concentration of EGFP in the IS: the hypothesis predicts that the points should fall on a line of slope ∼½. For the population of 57 rods, the ratio of outer segment core EGFP concentration to the maximal IS concentration was 0.51±0.04 (mean±95% confidence intervals). Thus, over an ∼300-fold concentration range differential EGFP binding is not distorting the profiles.
Arrestin-EGFP is not in equilibrium with the cytoplasm in dark adapted rods
Many important applications of EGFP arise from its capacity to serve in fusion proteins as a reporter for the locations and movements of proteins in cells. We took advantage of this capacity by examining the distribution of an arrestin-EGFP fusion protein (Arr-EGFP) expressed in rods under the Xenopus opsin promoter. In the dark-adapted state, Arr-EGFP is distributed differently from EGFP (Fig. 7A): first, the OS has less than 40% of the Arr-EGFP expected were the protein distributed freely (Fig. 7B,C); second, Arr-EGFP is concentrated in the region of the IS adjacent to the ellipsoid, and largely excluded from a broad region around the nucleus accessible to EGFP. Displays of the most intensely fluorescent voxels reveal the high concentration of Arr-EGFP just below and in a small pocket to one side of the ellipsoid (Fig. 7D).
Quantitative assessment of the light-induced redistribution of arrestin-EGFP
Bleaching of rhodopsin is thought to alter the distribution of arrestin by partitioning much of the soluble fraction onto the disc membranes of the outer segment, where rhodopsin resides (Mangini and Pepperberg, 1988; Mangini et al., 1994; Peterson et al., 2003). However, the immunocytochemical tools used to assess the apparent movement in some experiments have not permitted a quantitative evaluation of arrestin partitioning, and all or a portion of the apparent redistribution could reflect epitope masking as hypothesized to explain the light-dependent redistribution of transducin (Roof and Heth, 1988), and/or turnover of the protein (Azarian et al., 1995). We assessed the redistribution of Arr-EGFP in individual rods quantitatively after exposure of pieces of isolated retina to light that bleached all the rhodopsin (Fig. 8). By 30 minutes after the exposure, 40% of the Arr-EGFP initially in the IS had moved to the OS. This resulted in an almost twofold increase in the Arr-EGFP mass in the OS (Fig. 8B,C), including an increase at the very tip and a banding pattern, previously reported (Peterson et al., 2003). By 1 hour the Arr-EGFP distribution was reverting to its initial state. We derived the total mass of Arr-EGFP in each rod, integrating the fluorescence over the IS and OS, and comparing the sums in light and in darkness. Because conservation of mass is obeyed (Fig. 8C), we conclude that relocation of portions of an existing pool of Arr-EGFP in the IS, rather than protein synthesis or degradation, account for the redistributions in the hour following light exposure.
Our data may underestimate the full magnitude of the Arr-EGFP transfer in vivo. In a few rods more than 80% of the total Arr-EGFP was found to be initially in the IS, and up to 90% was found in the OS 30 minutes after bleaching. Exposure to the fluorescence excitation beam necessarily bleaches rhodopsin, and only cells closest to the floor of the chamber of the inverted microscope are in the fully dark adapted state when their confocal imaging commences.
The investigations reported here focus on the EGFP equilibration hypothesis, an hypothesis with broad implications for cell biology. We have tested this hypothesis quantitatively, shown it to be generative in producing novel insights into cell structure, and used it to reject the hypothesis that arrestin, a major soluble protein of phototransduction, is in equilibrium with the cytoplasm of dark-adapted rod cells, as we now discuss.
The cytoplasm as a `molecular sieve' and EGFP as a probe for aqueous spaces of living cells
The cytoplasm behaves as a `molecular sieve', so that molecules of different sizes have differing degrees of access to subcellular cytoplasmic spaces (Luby-Phelps, 2000). There is thus a need for macromolecular probes of the cytoplasm. The properties of EGFP make it an ideal probe for aqueous spaces and more specifically for the cytoplasm, as formalized in the EGFP equilibration hypothesis (see above section `EGFP equilibration hypothesis'). These properties include its high extinction coefficient (ϵmax=55,000 cm2 mmol-1) and fluorescence quantum efficiency (γ∼;0.7), its low photodestruction rate (∼10-7) and its exceptionally high mobility in cells (D/Do∼0.5) (Tsien, 1998; Luby-Phelps, 2000). The high mobility of EGFP in cells indicates that EGFP undergoes little or no binding interactions, and thus will equilibrate with the cytoplasm and communicating aqueous spaces rapidly. Our results showing that the ratio of fluorescence intensity of EGFP in the rod OS relative to the maximal fluorescence of the IS is independent of absolute level of expression, support the absence of specific binding interactions over the concentration range from 3 to 300 μM (Fig. 6).
The EGFP equilibration hypothesis passes qualitative and quantitative tests
Several features of the distribution of EGFP in rods are qualitatively consistent with the EGFP equilibration hypothesis. The ellipsoid region of the rod, which is packed with mitochondria (Fig. 5B,E-H), has lower EGFP fluorescence than neighboring regions of the IS and OS (Fig. 3B, Fig. 4B,C, Fig. 5A). The OS, whose volume is substantially occupied by disc membranes, also has reduced fluorescence (Fig. 3B, Fig. 4B, Fig. 5A). In contrast, the region of the IS around the nucleus and the synaptic spherule, which have relatively high cytoplasmic content, have relatively high EGFP fluorescence.
Rod ultrastructure provides a rigorous basis for a quantitative test of the EGFP equilibration hypothesis. Investigations of intact amphibian rods with X-ray diffraction, neutron diffraction and birefringence measurements have produced estimates of the cytoplasmic volume fraction of the OS core of ∼0.5 (Table 2). When these estimates are combined with the EGFP equilibration hypothesis, it is predicted that EGFP fluorescence in the core of the OS should be about 50% that of the most intensely fluorescing voxels of the IS. This prediction was confirmed and shown to be independent of expression level over a large concentration range (Figs 4, 6).
EGFP reveals novel features of the rod cytoplasm: the vestibule and the cytoplasmic cap
The distribution of EGFP in rod cells has revealed novel features of potential importance to the distribution of soluble proteins. One of these is the bright dot region localized to the ellipsoid immediately below the connecting cilium (Figs 3, 5). The EGFP equilibration hypothesis provides the basis for interpreting this spot as a region of increased water space available to soluble proteins immediately proximal to the connecting cilium, so we propose to name this space the `vestibule' to the connecting cilium and OS. These results draw attention to the role of the connecting cilium as a cytoplasmic conduit to the OS (Pulvermuller et al., 2002).
Another novel feature revealed by EGFP corresponds to an increase in fluorescence near the tip of the OS (Fig. 4, Fig. 6B). Prior work has demonstrated changes in the uptake of fluorescent probes (Matsumoto and Besharse, 1985) and in ultrastucture (Matsumoto et al., 1987) at the distal tip of Xenopus rods associated with the onset of disc shedding and phagocytosis. The EGFP equilibration hypothesis allows these changes to be interpreted as an increase in cytoplasmic space accompanying the preparation of the tip of the OS for phagocytosis. We propose to call this newly defined structure the `cytoplasmic cap' of the OS. An important structural correlation is that the rod axoneme has been found to terminate at about 2/3 the length of the OS (Kaplan et al., 1987), close to the position where the increase in cytoplasmic content begins (Fig. 4B,C).
Arrestin-EGFP disequilibrium in dark adapted rods
Arrestin is a soluble protein that binds phosphorylated rhodopsin, greatly reducing the latter's ability to activate the G-protein transducin in the visual cascade (Wilden et al., 1986; Xu et al., 1997). Our results establish definitively that Arr-EGFP is not in equilibrium with the cytoplasm of dark adapted rods (Fig. 7), and thus predict the existence of a mechanism that produces and maintains a disequilibrium in the dark adapted state. Since a large fraction of the Arr-EGFP in the IS can move rapidly to the OS when rhodopsin is bleached (Fig. 8), the mechanism that establishes the disequilibrium must be quickly reversible. Two plausible and non-exclusive hypotheses about the nature of the mechanism are these: (1) a signal-modulated `gate' near or in the connecting cilium; and (2) binding sites in the rod IS with strong, but lower effective affinity for arrestin than bleached and/or phosphorylated rhodopsin. A specific version of hypothesis 1 has been proposed (Pulvermuller et al., 2002), which provides evidence that the calcium-binding protein centrin-1 locates to the connecting cilium, and binds the visual transduction protein, Gtα. One way that a centrin-1-based mechanism might work is through a signal-dependent change in `sieving': thus, complex formation by proteins in the dark-adapted state could create a `sieve' in the connecting cilium that would only permit molecules of a certain size to transit. Our results suggest that EGFP is able to pass the most restrictive state of the sieve or gate, since the distribution of EGFP in the IS and OS in individual rods scanned with the CLSM when initially dark adapted, and re-scanned after they are fully bleached cells, is not materially different (Fig. 6).
In its simplest form, hypothesis 2 would specify that the apparent non-equilibrium distribution of arrestin-EGFP in the dark-adapted state reflects a differential binding in the IS and OS compartments. Thus, in the dark-adapted rod there would be a substantial population of arrestin binding sites in the IS combined with relatively few binding sites in the OS; bleaching of rhodopsin (whose concentration in the OS, in relation to the cytoplasm, is 6 mM) would then create a large population of binding sites, and arrestin would redistribute passively, as the soluble fraction in the OS partitions onto the disc membranes, in which the GPCR rhodopsin resides as an integral membrane protein. Mendez et al. have shown that light-dependent arrestin redistribution occurs in the absence of phosphorylation by the GPCR kinase GRK1 (Mendez et al., 2003). Their results reject the specific form of hypothesis 2 that identifies the light-dependent binding sites to be phosphorylated rhodopsin and, if the hypothesis is to be rescued, require the existence of light-dependent binding in the OS that is not dependent on phosphorylation by GRK1. Owing to the enormous concentration of rhodopsin in the OS, the hypothesis could remain viable if bleached but unphosphorylated opsin has weak affinity for arrestin, or if other binding sites such as membrane phosphoinositides are regulated by light, as has been shown for Drosophila photoreceptors (Lee et al., 2003).
Conservation of protein mass make it unlikely that de novo synthesis and/or degradation underlies the redistribution of arrestin-EGFP
The redistribution of arrestin upon strong bleaching of the rods of amphibia and mammals has been reported by many investigators (Broekhuyse et al., 1985; Broekhuyse et al., 1987; Philp et al., 1987; Mangini and Pepperberg, 1988; Whelan and McGinnis, 1988; Peterson et al., 2003; Mendez et al., 2003). Our results with Arr-EGFP show that this redistribution can be quantified in living rods in culture, opening the door to novel manipulations of mechanisms that might govern or affect the redistribution. Conservation of protein mass is obeyed over an hour period during the redistribution of Arr-EGFP to the OS, and redistribution of some of the protein back to the IS (Fig. 8C). This observation makes it unlikely that de novo synthesis and/or degradation contribute to the redistribution. Ongoing experiments are addressing the detailed time course and bleaching dependence of the redistribution. Knowledge of the cytoplasmic spaces of the rod will be critical to testing the hypothesis that arrestin redistribution is passive.
Problems for and further tests of the EGFP equilibration hypothesis
Critical to the estimation of the cytoplasmic volume fraction with EGFP is a satisfactory estimate of Fmax, which sets the scale for conversion of fluorescence intensity (Eqn 1; Fig. 4B,C). We used the average fluorescence of the voxels having intensities at and above the 95th percentile to estimate Fmax. This choice was based on the desire to have a statistically reliable sample and, for typical rods and CHO cells, 400 to 500 voxels were above the 95th percentile cuton. However, a 99th percentile criterion leads to ∼10% lower aqueous volume fraction estimate in pDP3 cells, and an approximately 5% lower estimate of that of the outer segment. These observations call for caution and further investigation of the intrinsic and experimental factors affecting estimation of Fmax.
Another problem for the EGFP equilibration hypothesis is that EGFP has access to the nucleoplasm (Keminer and Peters, 1999; Moritz et al., 1999) (Fig. 4, Fig. 5A,B). While such access does not per se exclude equilibration with the cytoplasm, it places additional constraints and could under some conditions perturb the equilibrium distribution, and calls attention to a key assumption of the hypothesis, namely that EGFP is distributed rapidly in a cell relative to any transients in translation and/or proteolysis. We have observed no measurable changes in the distribution of EGFP in single rod cells over periods exceeding 1.5 hours, including periods before and after exposure to light that completely bleaches all the rhodopsin (Fig. 6A). Calculations based on the time for small fluorescent probes to reach equilibrium in rods in which diffusion is greatly hindered (Olson and Pugh, 1993) suggest that equilibration with a step source of EGFP in the inner segment should take no more than tens of minutes in rods. Thus, given a half-life ∼1 day (Verkhusha et al., 2003) one would expect the distribution of EGFP to be equilibrated in small cells. Nonetheless, it will be important to measure the time course of equilibration of EGFP and other GFP variants from point sources, and quantify the stability of the apparent equilibrium distribution - experiments we are actively pursuing.
This work was supported by the Research to Prevent Blindness Foundation (grants NIH EY02660, EY12975, EY12910) and the Human Frontiers of Science Program. We thank J. K. Blasie for helpful discussion of rod X-ray diffraction data and V. Y. Arshavsky for valuable comments. We are grateful to F. Letterio, J. Andrews-Labenski, E. L. Lu and R. Weldon for valuable assistance.
Movies and supplemental data available online
- Accepted February 19, 2004.
- © The Company of Biologists Limited 2004