Circadian oscillators of Drosophila and mammals

Starting from mid-day (top right), two basic-helix-loop-helix/PAS domain transcription factors, CLOCK (CLK) and CYCLE (CYC), form heterodimers and bind E-box regulatory elements (CACGTG) to activate per and tim transcription. Although per and tim mRNA levels accumulate during this phase of the circadian cycle, PER and TIM protein levels do not. TIM remains at low levels because it is destabilized by light (see below). PER is phosphorylated by DOUBLE-TIME (DBT) kinase and, without TIM, is targeted for degradation by the ubiquitin/proteasome pathway (reviewed by Harms et al., 2004). PER phosphorylation is also dependent on casein kinase 2 (CK2), which is believed to be a primer kinase for DBT, and protein phosphatase 2a (PP2a), which dephosphorylates PER (Allada and Meissner, 2005; Harms et al., 2004). The coordinated effects of kinases and phosphatases during this time keep PER at low levels and in a hypophosphorylated state because hyperphosphorylated PER is degraded owing to low TIM levels.

After sundown (bottom right), per and tim continue to be transcribed and their mRNAs reach peak levels during the early evening. TIM begins to accumulate in the dark and forms a complex with PER and DBT, thereby stabilizing PER despite continued phosphorylation by DBT and CK2. As a result, PER and TIM accumulate to high levels during the middle of the night (bottom left). As DBT-PER-TIM accumulates, phosphorylation of TIM by SHAGGY (SGG) is believed to be a crucial step that triggers DBT, PER and TIM entry into the nucleus (Harms et al., 2004). Although these proteins enter the nucleus at about the same time, PER-DBT and TIM enter the nucleus separately (Hall, 2003). Once in the nucleus, PER-DBT or re-formed DBT-PER-TIM complexes bind to CLK-CYC, which represses transcription of per, tim and other genes by removing CLK-CYC from E-boxes and promotes DBT-dependent hyperphosphorylation of CLK (Hardin, 2005). The ∼6-hour delay between per and tim transcription and accumulation of PER and TIM proteins in the nucleus is thought to be a critical determinant of circadian period. By the end of the night, TIM levels begin to decline through an as yet uncharacterized mechanism.

At dawn (top left), a light-induced conformational change in the blue-light photoreceptor cryptochrome (CRY) promotes the formation of CRY-TIM complexes, TIM degradation by the ubiquitin/proteasome pathway, and CRY destabilization (Ashmore and Sehgal, 2003). PER and CLK are also degraded during the early morning, but their degradation is promoted by DBT-dependent phosphorylation (Hardin, 2005). Although PER falls to its lowest levels by the middle of the day (top right), CLK levels remain relatively constant because hypophosphorylated CLK is generated by new CLK synthesis or PP2a-dependent dephosphorylation of hyperphosphorylated CLK (Kim and Edery, 2006; Yu et al., 2006). Hypophosphorylated CLK then forms a heterodimer with CYC and binds to E-boxes to initiate a new cycle of per and tim transcription (Hardin, 2005). The per/tim feedback loop is a necessary component of the circadian oscillator since per-null and tim-null mutants each abolish circadian oscillator function.

Interlocked with the per/tim feedback loop is a second feedback loop in Clk transcription. Two additional CLK-CYC target genes, vrille (vri) and PAR domain protein 1ϵ (Pdp1ϵ), are activated by E-box binding at mid-day (top right). Although vri mRNA accumulates in phase with per and tim mRNAs, Pdp1ϵ RNA accumulation is delayed by several hours (Hardin, 2004). In contrast to the delayed accumulation of PER and TIM, VRI levels rise in concert with vri mRNA. As VRI accumulates in the nucleus during the mid to late day, it binds VRI/PDP1ϵ binding sites (V/P-boxes) [consensus A(/G)TTA(/T)T(/C):GTAAT(/C)], to repress Clk and cry transcription (Hardin, 2004). VRI protein reaches peak levels during the early evening (bottom right), which is coincident with low levels of Clk and cry mRNAs. Despite the low levels of cry mRNA, CRY begins to accumulate because it is relatively stable in the dark (Ashmore et al., 2003).

Whereas PDP1ϵ accumulates to peak levels during the mid to late night (bottom-left), VRI levels decline during this time owing to DBT-PER-dependent repression of vri transcription. The rising ratio of PDP1ϵ/VRI favors binding of PDP1ϵ to V/P-boxes, which activates Clk and cry transcription (Hardin, 2004). PDP1ϵ levels start to decline during the late evening, and are low by the early morning (top left). However, small amounts of PDP1ϵ may continue to activate Clk and cry transcription until the middle of the day, when VRI starts to accumulate after the next cycle of CLK-CYC transcription is initiated (top right).

The Clk feedback loop necessarily drives rhythmic transcription in the opposite phase as the per/tim loop because CLK-CYC activates E-box transcription and represses V/P-box transcription around dusk, and DBT-PER (or DBT-PER-TIM) represses E-box transcription and activates V/P-box transcription around dawn (Hardin, 2004). In addition to driving rhythms in per, tim, vri, Pdp1ϵ, Clk and cry expression, these feedback loops drive rhythms in the expression of ∼150 clock output genes (Wijnen et al., 2006). For example, the slowpoke (slo) Ca²⁺-dependent voltage-gated potassium channel and the SLO-binding protein (slob) genes are rhythmically expressed (Ceriani et al., 2002; Jaramillo et al., 2004), which suggests that aspects of neurotransmission are under clock control. Since Clk and cry mRNA cycling do not control CLK and CRY levels or activity, the Clk feedback loop may be more important for controlling rhythmic outputs than for sustaining circadian oscillator function.

As in Drosophila, the circadian oscillator in mammals is composed of interlocked transcriptional feedback loops. Many components of the Drosophila circadian oscillator have orthologs and/or functional equivalents in mammals. In fact, the Drosophila circadian oscillator depicted in the poster can be converted to a mammalian circadian oscillator by making the following changes (see blue lettering and arrows in center): CLOCK-BMAL1 replaces CLK-CYC, mPER-mCRY replaces PER-TIM, CK1ϵ replaces DBT, REV-ERBα replaces VRI, RORa replaces PDP1ϵ, RORE elements replace V/P-boxes, and PP2a, SGG, CK2 and CRY are removed. Several differences in the structure or function of these mammalian clock components are notable. mPER-mCRY functions to repress CLOCK-BMAL1 transcription, but mCRY is the major repressor as opposed to PER in flies (Reppert and Weaver, 2002). Although CRY functions as a circadian photoreceptor in flies, its role as a transcriptional repressor has been retained in at least some fly peripheral tissues (Collins et al., 2006). REV-ERBα and RORa are nuclear receptors rather than bZIP transcription factors like VRI and PDP1ϵ, and they regulate transcription by binding RORE elements rather than V/P-boxes (Bell-Pedersen et al., 2005). Although the circadian oscillator mechanisms of Drosophila and mammals show striking similarities, their entrainment to light differs markedly. In flies, light entrains the circadian oscillator by inducing TIM degradation, whereas light entrains the mammalian oscillator by inducing Per1 transcription (Reppert and Weaver, 2002). Since light can directly entrain Drosophila oscillators (Ashmore and Sehgal, 2003), but indirectly entrains mammalian oscillators (Reppert and Weaver, 2002), it is not surprising that different mechanisms have evolved in these animals.